Holly Khun, known to Chicago as “Miss Christmas,” always finds a beautiful tree for the plaza, but this year’s was damaged, and the lighting ceremony is in 10 days. Hoping for a miracle, she combs through fan mail, and finds Joey McNary of Klaus, Wisconsin, has the perfect tree. Off she goes to Klaus, where she meets Joey’s handsome dad Sam.

• Brooke D'Orsay
• Marc Blucas
• Luke Roessler
• Erin Boyes
• Fiona Vroom
• James Rha
• Greg Rogers
• Crystal Balint